Antique-shop.com
Antiques! => Antique Questions Forum => Topic started by: umiumisumi on January 07, 2014, 11:00:08 am
-
Hi all, I'm new here.
I just received a family heirloom that I would love to know more about and see if it can be restored at all.
Here is the history that I know of this item:
My grandmother's family was Polish and Ukranian Catholic (My grandmother was born around 1915), and this item is supposed to be handed down to the oldest daughter in the family. I don't believe they lived in Poland, as the family ended up as refugees in China after the Communist revolution, and so likely lived either in Russia or another Soviet-bloc state. I had originally hoped that this was an Orthodox icon, but I think it looks more like a Catholic Madonna from what I've seen on the internet.
There is an inscription on the back which I have included a pic. I had a Polish friend take a look at it, as my mom thinks it was written in Polish, but it is in Russian and reads as follows: "Restored by Hadzhi Met. 1955" and has a location in Switzerland. The same thing appears to be written in Italian as well.
Anyhow, I would love any input about this item, or referrals to someone that may know more about this kind of item.
Pics are attachments to this post. I can get closer/more pictures if anyone wants.
Thank you!
Sumi
-
Is this done on metal ??
-
It looks like plaster on canvas.
-
Can you take a closer pic of the front so we can see any detail ??
-
Mart, it won't let me enlarge and even though I enlarge it on my screen can't see well enoug either.
What does the ornamentation appear to be made of? Beads from shell or Bakelite? or Pearls? Strung with string or metal? Or could it appear to be "cat gut"?
Stitching through to the back?
Better close ups would help some...but really need your observations as well.
Glad to have you here!
-
Yes I know !! I can`t see it either !! I am assuming there were faces painted at one time !! This looks more like a folk art piece than anything "made" to sell !! Perhaps done by one of their family members then passed down !!
-
Hi! Thank you all for taking a look at this for me. Here's more photos, I'll try to post them in a larger format if I can.
There are definitely faces, everything painted looks either very oxidized or dirty...
The adornments appear to be beads and bows. The frame is pretty well sealed with glass on the front.
I think I can only get 1 large pic per post, so here's a detail of the Child
-
Madonna's face
-
Here is a close-up showing the canvas or some other textile underneath. Beads also visible.
-
Certainly has an Orthodox appearance to the painting/backing. Would love to see this in daylight.
Wondering if the beads were added later, over a period of time, to disguise the gradual deterioration of the painting?
-
Those close ups help !! Thanks !! It looks like a just a heavy gesso on the canvas !! My suggestion would be to take it out of the frame and clean it before you decide on what else it needs !! If the frame was not sealed well its possible that smoke and dust found its way into it !! Perhaps your family used a fireplace ?? Would be a painstaking process with a bunch of Q-Tips but its possibly just dirty !! May not need restoration !! I personally would leave it as original as possible !!
-
Mart, do you think that it could possibly be egg tempera that was used. Was doing a quick search trying to find similar subjects and came across a site that sells Russian icons. One that was vaguely similar (plus several others) are described as using egg tempera. On reading up on the tempera it is mentioned that it needed to be applied to a stiff backing (such as wood) and using it on canvas would cause crackling and pieces of the paint to fall off.
This is the site I was looking at………
http://www.russianstore.com/icons1.htm
and the icon that led me there (egg tempera/gilding on wood)
-
Thanks for the feedback everyone. I'll try to get a photo in natural light tomorrow, but it's hard to get a clear image without a big reflection because of the glass. The frame is VERY well sealed, as far as I can tell. Pretty darned sturdy.
The beaded portion is on canvas, but the faces seem to be recessed below the canvas portion, which reminds me of more modern Russian Orthodox style icons, so it is possible that the faces are painted onto something more solid.
I'm super scared to open the frame on my own... I'm in northern CA, does anyone know of someplace/someone I could take this to to get it looked at? Otherwise, we'll just put her someplace in our home that she's not going to spook out visitors. (She's been in my parents' garage for the last 30 years because she's just a little too creepy for them. I'm in the process of becoming Orthodox, so I'm not as weirded out by old icons as they are....)
-
You know, I think she may be a version of the "Black Madonna":
http://www.marypages.com/Czestochowa2.gif
That would make sense, because of the Polish connection.
-
I have some icons I brought back from my travels and they are painted on wood - very common. Have one painted on cardboard, one on silk, etc.
Have seen white Madonna's, brown, black, etc. So not sure what the original color scheme was.
Canvas wasn't that easy to come by even way back when for the Russian/Ukraine areas (except for those better off). Many were very resourceful. I was wondering...if it is a more delicate material used that is adhered to the wood.
I personally wouldn't do anything to it until I would find out more about it and would keep asking and get a "hands-on" inspection.
Family heirloom.
-
In the closeup pic of the child, when enlarged…….does that look more like a burlap type weave? A coarser 'thread' and much larger/uneven spacing than canvas?
-
I would agree that it does look coarse. I hadn't considered burlap as a substrate.
-
Anything is possible !! Looking closer I agree it doesn`t look like a canvas fabric as we know it !! Depending on age could be an egg tempura !! I do see what you are talking about with the face !! Looks like a border of fabric around it but all is difficult without a hands on inspection !! Any reputable frame shop or art gallery should be able to remove the frame without damage !! Except for a few,, I think the beads have been added over time by family members and are not a part of the original work !! You really need to do some family research to find out !! Or they could have been added after a death of a family member as a remembrance !! Maybe the beads were from a favorite piece of jewelry !! You did say that it was handed down through the females in the family ?? Mother to daughter didn,`t you ??
-
Mart, stringing of beads and bead work has been a long standing tradition in Russia and the Ukraine area for a v-e-r-y long time. It was one of those handicrafts that girls were taught (mainly needlework (“nyzynka”), embroidery, crewel embroidery in English terms) which is a dying art and some are trying to revive there. Beading was taught as well, but not as prevalent because of the cost of beads, but still taught.
I do think this was a piece of family handiwork and a great Family Heirloom. If in fact the story is correct, this has been a treasured piece in this family and people have worked hard to preserve it. Once you do find out the correct composition of the piece you should compile the information and attach it to the back of the frame so that future generations can try and get the depth of importance of the piece!
-
I'm really torn on what to do with this icon... She is a family heirloom, but she is in very, very poor shape and I don't know if she can be fixed up (or if she could I'm not sure I have the funds to pay someone to do it.) The Orthodox are very serious about their icons, and I'm seeking advice from more knowledgeable Orthodox on what I should do with her. It may be more respectful to her to have her 'decommissioned' and respectfully disposed of as is custom for icons that are badly damaged. I'll keep you all updated on what we end up doing with her.
-
You might consider taking it to a reputable museum and asking their opinion !! They can work wonders with art pieces !! Get an estimate from them as to the cost of a restoration,,my opinion is that just a good cleaning would help !! Even though you think it is well sealed,, it may not be !! They can give you the best recommendations !! If you decommission the piece,,much of your family history goes with it so that is something to think about !! And yes please keep us updated on your decision !!
-
Well said Mart!
-
Would be sad to see it go after being passed down for so many years !!