I meant to get back on here and post again. Thanks for the responses. Yeh, still never heard back and the last I knew that he was going to mail it back. I don't have a limit on days for the returns because I put no returns on there, but as we all know it is pointless to put no returns accepted, when ebay makes you take returns/do refunds anyway. I would think after all this time, that I wouldn't have to refund.
I would be shocked if he returned it another 2 months down the road just to make me mad.
R&R I can't believe that that lady left you a bad feedback for her grand daughter breaking that doll. Yet, on the other hand it doesn't surprise me though. I have seen people leave negatives on several things they bought from different people like that is all they do is leave bad feedback. Some people just like to complain. I believe that some like to get something for nothing too (scamming with trying to get us to refund and they never return it). I was going to put a few things on my husband's account but I think he is afraid of someone trying to do that with the negative. He has a perfect score so far and has always sold reproduction arrowheads on there that he made himself (he is around 1050).
That guy who never returned the item hasn't left me feedback yet (although I haven't looked lately).