You are correct Wull, I resurrected "Holy Guacamole" from the original Batman. What can I say, sometimes the classics speak for themelves.
You all are amazing detectives! I think you've found it. Mine is indeed almost 2 feet high, but also measures 18" on each side, so I think we've got the same manufacturer. I got this ballot box from my grandfather, a longtime Kansas City resident, but he also spent time in Colorado, so it's possible he picked it up there.
Of course $1800 would be wonderful, but $250 is OK as well. It didn't cost me anything, and I'll probably keep it as a remembrance of my grandfather for the rest of my life anyway. I'm biased of course, but I'll take mine over the ones with the turned piers.
Thanks again for all your sleuthing!