Mart, I acquired it in Indiana but understand from the seller that her sister had acquired in New York over 25 years ago at auction. Given the size and number of lights leans me towards French, but the construction doesn't seem indicative of that origin. It also has a Gothic vibe to it, but knowing that it probably had crystals steers me away from that assumption. The rosettes are not glass, but plastic which leads me to believe they are replacements. I realize will probably never know the manufacturer. Originally had thought late 19th C, but now I'm thinking it dates to early 1900-1910s? Not sure what to look for to make that call either way. Thanks for the input! Any idea on what you'd put as a resale value?