Wow! Antique-shop.com forums are in the big #1 spot on Google for the search term "antique shop forum", for 4 years running!Thanks to YOU.
olecanal, your best bet would be to find a "best match" one from a supplier such as, to wit: http://woodworker.com/3-14x3-12-embossed-onlay-oak-mssu-113-360.asp and paint it to match